R1200GS Forum banner

2005 R1200GS - What controls my idle? (It's stalling out)

25K views 11 replies 5 participants last post by  gdayjr  
#1 ·
Hi Folks,

I've been suffering some odd idle issues of late. When it's cold, it's fine, starts right up. This issue seems to come and go, and I've not figured out what the issue is.

The first time it stalled on me, I got off a highway and was on some secondary roads, pulled in the clutch and poof, went out. It didn't buck or stumble or struggle, just shut right off. It did this for the rest of the ride home, unless I gave it a bit of throttle, it would stall out.

Next day, started right up, and gave me no issues at all...

During the weekend, I did a valve adjustment, new plugs, airfilter. It was due. Bike still ran fine, for may be a day or two, then started stalling again.

I looked into syncing the throttle bodies and found that they're not done like my older 1100 series. I understand them to be 'preset' from factory and now uses some stepper motors, which, only can be monkeyed with by the throttle cables, to some extent, but that's more of just making sure it has some mm of free play or something... I did tinker with the throttle cables a touch, with a carb sync tool plugged in -- that seemed to give me a much more steady idle once I was done.

It's been a couple weeks now, and it's now started doing it again! This morning though, I have more details. No issue getting off the first highway, no issue on the backroad connectors to my next highway.... and this next highway I only go up one exit. During this travel, I was feeling a touch zesty and ... gave her some pepper. I brought it up to about 6 or 7k rpm in 5th gear. I touched triple digits, had my grin, and decelerated back down as I got off the highway doing about 60mph. I rolled through the first light, took my turn and shifted slowly - and poof she was out again. it continued to do this for the next 4 mins or so -- stalling out if I didn't hold some throttle. I got to the guard gate at work where I have to show ID to get in and it stalled out 3x on me there. Got her fired up and pulled forward in first, pulled the clutch and poof out she goes again instantly.

So, some other things of note:

I've seen it idle at 1800ish rpm.
I've seen it stall out or idle at 800ish rpm.
When it stalls it never does a coughing death. It's instant. Just poof, out.

So, what should I try? I don't have a GS911, and I generally don't use a dealer... but I may be doing both!

Dave
 
#2 ·
Generally, you've done the right things. Valve adjustment and TB sync. On the sync though, make sure both cables have a little slack before you adjust. Also, sync at a speed above idle so the stepper motors don't mess with the idle. Plus, they will always affect idle so sync at 2-3k rpm and that will help.

GS-911 helps some on the sync since you can park the steppers, but syncing above idle gets around that.

The only other thing is the simple reset of the throttle position sensor, but I'm not so sure it will do much in this situation. It helps more with idle in cold, but it is simple and won't hurt a thing. So, turn on ignition, but don't start bike. Smoothly open throttle all the way and close. Do this 3 times. Not fast and not really slow. Turn off ignition, then turn it on and start bike. All this does is tell the computer where full open and closed is. Sometimes that helps with poor idling.

Back to your problem, I helped a guy with the same thing and it took a good valve check and sync to make it go away. One of his throttle cables didn't have enough slack either so that interfered with the sync he did on his own.
 
#3 ·
Generally, you've done the right things. Valve adjustment and TB sync. On the sync though, make sure both cables have a little slack before you adjust. Also, sync at a speed above idle so the stepper motors don't mess with the idle. Plus, they will always affect idle so sync at 2-3k rpm and that will help.

GS-911 helps some on the sync since you can park the steppers, but syncing above idle gets around that.

The only other thing is the simple reset of the throttle position sensor, but I'm not so sure it will do much in this situation. It helps more with idle in cold, but it is simple and won't hurt a thing. So, turn on ignition, but don't start bike. Smoothly open throttle all the way and close. Do this 3 times. Not fast and not really slow. Turn off ignition, then turn it on and start bike. All this does is tell the computer where full open and closed is. Sometimes that helps with poor idling.

Back to your problem, I helped a guy with the same thing and it took a good valve check and sync to make it go away. One of his throttle cables didn't have enough slack either so that interfered with the sync he did on his own.
 
#4 ·
I may look into pulling my throttle cables and lubing them. The bike does have 53k miles on it. It seems odd to me that I suffer this on the hot side of running vs cold.

I'll give the throttle open - close a shot. Can't hurt anything I suppose!

Seeing as it comes and goes for me though sticking cable strikes me as a possibility -- like plastics expanding or shrinking when heated, etc.

I'm curious how hard the cable job is on one of these... ;)

Thanks for the thoughts!

Dave
 
#5 ·
Well, I fired the bike up and it idled perfectly right out of the gate. I was putting my gear on as I spoke with another bike guy at work and it started bucking a bit... raising idle, lowering idle, couple of coughs.

Knowing that it was either going to get me home, or I'd have to tow it, I hopped on and rode it. I have one of those little farkles that sit on the throttle and can hold a position, so I put that in place so that it wouldn't stall -- and I noticed that as I pull my brake, it would raise the idle by 1k... I thought that seems odd. Might just be something to do with me holding the throttle while braking, but not positive.

Got on the highway - did nice smooth riding with no issues... got off the highway -- and zero problems. Back to perfect idle, I can't get it to stall out. Worked great for the next 30 mins of back roads with zero issue.

Dave
 
#6 ·
So, here's another tidbit.

It began stalling again, and I thought perhaps it's fuel related. I've heard the evap canister (charcoal canister) could be the issue, some sort of pressure/vacuum issue.

It stalled, I pulled out the key, popped open the gas cap and fired it back up. I could not get it to stall!

I went home, pulled the charcoal canister, put a cap on the little plastic valve thingie and fired it up for a rip around the block. aaaand it started stalling again.

It seems it's every time I get heavy on the throttle, then it acts up. Still no clue. :confused:

Dave
 
#7 ·
The canister is a filter for the air that escapes from the tank when it gets hot. Plus it allows air back in. If no air comes back into the tank then a vacuum forms and the fuel won't flow, hence the stalling. If you plugged the hose that used to go to the canister then you made it worse. It needs to be open to the air.

Over filling the gas tank can cause fuel to fill the canister when the fuel expands in the tank and also cause rough running and stalling.

So it sounds like you are on to the solution, but don't plug the tank vent.
 
#8 ·
Answered your own question




I think you seemed to have sorted it out, and then by accident created exactly the same issue by plugging the return tube.
As stated above the tank needs to "breath" to work properly, the charcoal filter is not fitted on bikes for the Australian market, so we don't get that issue here.
 
#9 ·
stalling issues

There is a procedure to do a "canistorectomy" on a 2005, I've done mine and it's worked fine even overfilled. I'd be sure you followed that.

You've done the standard stuff but the hot vs. cold is a clue that you've got a problem with fuel venting. Have you had the fuel pump gasket recall done? Has the tank been off recently?
 
#10 ·
Sorry for such a late response -- I found the stalling a few days later -- when the plug just fell out of the left air sensor. A bit of a bad design, that it can be there, look right but just not be finally clipped in... clearly I bumped it's little metal clip thing in the woods with my leg, or something.

Well, live n' learn. Unplugged and replugged it in. Been fine for many miles since! I had no dirt/grime in that connection, but clearly it was just not making proper connection.

Dave aka Ghan